1. Introduction & Background


The concept of False Starts came from my first explorations of abandoned settler communities in Southwestern Manitoba, specifically those that blossomed briefly, when would-be farmers, most of them from Ontario, ventured west from Winnipeg and Portage La Prairie along the Assiniboine River and established a series of communities along that river and along the Souris River, beginning in 1878.  Those first small villages, naturally placed along the main waterways of the southwest corner, existed for only a few years before they were abruptly replaced with the arrival of the railway. I thought of those villages as False Starts, the underlying assumption being that the new towns, created to conform to the new transportation reality, were the opposite of False Starts – they were somehow legitimate or lasting propositions.

And they did last. Some of them. For a while.

But then things changed again. Just as those first villages, often along rivers, gave way to new villages placed along railway lines, the next transportation revolution, the automobile, dictated that successful towns would be on major highways.

My impression was that the concept of False Starts was unique to the early settlement era, and was just a matter of timing.  Of course pre-railroad villages had existed for decades elsewhere in our province and elsewhere on the continent. It was just that settlement didn’t reach into this corner of the province until railways were also approaching. The short-lived pre-railroad villages in Southwestern Manitoba didn’t get their start until the need for that sort of village was about to disappear.

It was like buying a brand-new, state-of-the-art VCR, just before DVD’s came on the market.

Thus in the longer view of history, all settlements, all towns, even societies, cultures, communities, business ventures, and political movements, can be seen as False Starts.  Hindsight is more reliable than placing a wager.

The area had been carefully explored however and this map shows many of the region's geographic features that we know well today.

 

* From Laurie's 1870 map of Western Canada


In the 1870's, Southwestern Manitoba had no established agricultural communities. The fur trade was essentially over in the region and former posts along the Souris River near Hartney and at Souris Mouth had been closed for some time. The buffalo were beginning the steep decline that would see them almost exterminated by 1880.

The so-called “settlement” of the West itself was a False Start in the sense that at the time, and for some time, we seemed to overlook the fact that this land was, and had been, already settled. We’re still sorting that out, but as we proceed let’s remember that the history of Southwestern Manitoba didn’t begin in 1878.

That’s not to say that a False Start was always a mistake. Quite the opposite. False Starts are initiatives. They can be mistakes. Planning a town called Moberly on the swampy southwest corner of Whitewater Lake, and marketing it as a lakeside paradise, wasn’t wise. It wasn’t even legal.

But most False Starts are the necessary steps in finding our way. Explorations. Test cases.
When faced with a choice between the uncertain path and staying home, it’s a good thing that humans forge ahead.

When William Francis Butler stepped off of the deck of the steamer International as it prepared to dock near the forks of the Assiniboine and Red Rivers in the fall of 1869, the frontier settlement of Winnipeg was not yet the capital of the region and the region was not yet the province of Manitoba. Mr. Butler was on a mission, a mission that related to the creation of the province. He was there to meet with Riel and get a feel for the situation.  1

That mission, a delicate one, carried out with tact and competence, likely had little impact on the outcome of the confrontation that gave birth to our province. But his other mission, that of exploring this new land, had a more impact than he would have imagined. Butler wrote an account of his travels, which he published as "The Great Lone Land", and that book painted a picture of the west that caught peoples imagination and inspired some of them to check it out for themselves.

Quite a few came to what we now call Western Manitoba, perhaps in a sense, arriving before it was fully open for business. Like gatecrashers at a concert or at a holiday sale in a big box store, they learned patience. And a few other things.

In 1879 there were still few settlers hardy enough to leave the security of the Red River and Lower Assiniboine valleys and push west.

That was about to change.

That region, still officially part of the Northwest Territories, was sparsely populated at the time, but that had not always been so. The wooded valleys of both the Assiniboine and Souris Rivers and their tributaries had long provided wood and shelter for Nakota, Dakota and Ojibway camps, and more recently, Metis buffalo hunters. Archaeological expeditions are currently helping us decipher the unwritten records of the first peoples, while written records start with the French Canadian explorers and traders.

The Nakota (whom we called the Assiniboine) brought LaVerendrye and his party fifty-two men from the Red River in 1738. He travelled with his brother, two sons, one slave, twenty-one hired hands, and a group of natives. We may chuckle a bit at the mistakes in his maps, they relied on hearsay to fill in the parts he hadn't actually visited, but he managed in a relatively short time to provide what was effectively a quantum leap in terms of recorded knowledge of the area. His primary interest was in exploration, but he needed the profits from the fur trade to finance explorations. His business mission was to outflank the HBC and he tolerated the time that trading took away from his real interest. - the search for the "Western Sea".

After LaVerendrye, came the traders. They built forts in an ever-expanding reach from the forks of the Red and Assiniboine. They learned to live in this land, with invaluable help from the Aboriginal people, and they learned that agriculture was possible outside of the Red River Valley. That led to the first wave of homesteaders in the "Manitoba Boom" of 1878-1882. These were the people who started the process of conversion to an agriculturally based society and economy.

It is far too easy to summarize that process, as our school history books did, as some sort of inevitable evolution - a sort of pre-ordained progress of mankind. There was a well-orchestrated effort to portray this “new” land as empty. It wasn't. That story is being well told elsewhere and I won’t dwell on it here, but I will certainly acknowledge it. Let me just say that “Truth and Reconciliation” begins with “Truth”. We’re working on it.

What did the first European settlers find here?

Wouldn't it be nice to have more photographs or even sketches of the landscape! The ones we do have coupled with the excellent written accounts do help us form a picture.

First, the expression "Bald Prairie" did indeed apply. Almost all accounts from pioneers mention the availability of wood as a matter of importance. When riversides and other wooded places were taken, few remaining farm sites had trees, and the hauling and sale of wood became a source of ready employment for those with access.

Alexander Henry, while travelling across country from Brandon House to Fort Ash in 1806, noted the great view he had from the hills after stopping at a small lake, which must have been Lake Clementi, directly south of Brandon. He mentions seeing where the "Rapid" River empties into the Assiniboine. As it is a distance of some 25 km I suspect that what he saw was the trees on the banks of those rivers, and that because that was almost the only place trees could be found, he correctly assumed that the river was hidden. 2

One hundred years is a short time, in the geological, and even geographical sense. And although a comparative set of snapshots of the same stretch of land, one dated 1880, and another dated 2020, would reveal very real differences; those differences are the result of our intervention on the land. We made the changes.



Henry Youle Hind's 1858 expedition, camped along the Souris River. (3)

The photograph above, taken in 1859 is one of the first photos taken in southwestern Manitoba. The photographer was Humphrey Lloyd Hime a photographer and surveyor recruited to provide a photographic record of an exploring expedition.
The trees grew because the prairie fires stopped, and because cultivation altered the drainage. The trees, in turn, further altered drainage. Altered drainage likely changed the nature of the rivers,
and streams. But, underneath it all, if you get away from the roads and highways, from the population centres, from the well-tilled fields, you will find the land much as it was.
It was, by most accounts, harsh, yet inviting. It is difficult to get a real picture because the accounts left are so subjective. The impressions of the first European settlers were colored by their hopes and dreams. They recount what to us might seem incredible hardships with a matter-of-fact sort of shrug. One gets the feeling that they sometimes reported only the highlights - and that they accepted from the outset that the hardships came, literally, with the territory.
I think that most of the “pioneers”, like the early fur traders, were so entranced by the newness and the openness of the place that they tended to ignore the loneliness and the harshness of the climate. They were caught up in the excitement of their individual endeavours - leaving the old behind, striking out towards the new. They were just too busy and too distracted by their dreams to pay much attention to trivial details like weather and lack of amenities. And they kept coming.
Not all of them stayed, but many of them thrived.
By 1876 the survey was making its way westward, ahead of the first European settlers who were to arrive at Grand Valley, just above the Rapids noted at the top centre of this map, and at Millford, near the junction of the Souris and Assiniboine.
Surveyor's maps published annually between 1879 and 1882 show that the southwest corner went from being empty - to being nearly full. Well, not quite full - it took a few more years for the dust from the Manitoba boom to settle. While most of the land had been claimed and/or purchased by 1882, it took another decade to separate the speculators from the homesteaders, the buyers from the actual settlers.
The little square sections on the map filled up. The names were shuffled. Many newcomers found that the well-marketed campaign to attract settlement had oversold the attractions of the new land and decided it wasn’t for them. Some learned that farming wasn’t for
5
 
them. Their names were replaced by the newcomers. This slowed and the population stabilized. Many prospered.
Then the towns sprang up as increasing income caused the need for services to skyrocket. Many of the first towns didn't survive the transition from the era of rapid expansion to the era of entrenchment and economic growth. They had been situated along the first highways - the riverbanks. And although the exact locations were chosen with an eye towards the coming railway, that factor involved guesswork, and a good dose of optimism. The new towns of the 1990's were based on actual rail lines not proposed ones, and there were many of them. No one wanted to travel far to deliver their produce, or to purchase supplies, and with the spread of the rail lines, they didn't have to.
The cycle of increased production leading to increased purchasing spiraled through the first few decades of the new century, and after a sobering interlude in the thirties, renewed its march into the early forties.
Then the next change began. Increasingly large and mechanically sophisticated farm machinery made it possible for one family to farm thousands of acres. Increasing costs of production made it seem necessary to do so. The townships (36 sections or square miles of land) that once supported from fifty to a hundred families now were home to fewer and fewer. Rural depopulation began. And like the spiral of supply and demand that created the rural towns, a new, downward spiral left buildings abandoned on every other old farm site, and empty fields where towns once stood.
Drive through western Manitoba, and you will see fields of wheat larger than the entire farm I once called home. That field can be harvested in a few hours by a combine costing more than our half- section farm was worth. A hog barn staffed by just a few men produces more pork per month than an entire municipality would ship to market in years. The era of corporate agriculture began and our pioneer past has become even more remote.
But it would be so nice to stand on a hilltop and see the land as it was in those days before the ox and plow were replaced by the
tractor, and before the crooked dirt trail was replaced by the straight smooth pavement.




Map of the Province of Manitoba and Part of the District of Kewatin and North West Territory (1876).





Online Resources:

Begg, Alexander: Ten years in Winnipeg (1879)
Bryce, George: Holiday Rambles Between Winnipeg and Victoria (1888)
Bryce, George: John Black, the Apostle of Red Rivber
Bryce, George: Manitoba: Its infancy, growth, and present condition (1882)
Butler, William Francis: The Great Lone Land
Carle, Frank Austin: The British Northwest (1881)
D'Artigue, Jean: Six Years in the Canadian North-West
Dawson, McDonell:  The North-West Territories and British Columbia (1881)
First Days, Fighting Days : Women in Manitoba History
Girard, Senate Hearings / CPR West Railway Line, 1877
Grant, George M.: Sanford Flemings Expedition Through Canada in 1872 (1877)
Hill, Robert Brown: Manitoba: History of itsEarly Settlement...(1890)
Hind, Henry, Youle: North-West Territory: Reports of Progress (1859)
Macounn, John: Manitoba & the Great Northwest
McClung, Nellie: Clearing In The West
MacDougall, W.B. MacDougall's Illustrated Guide, gazetteer and practical hand-book for Manitoba and the North-West, 1882
McKenzie, Nathaniel : The men of the Hudson's Bay Company, 1670 A.D.-1920 A.D . 1921.